Why Be Good?
- February 28, 1929 (1929-02-28)
English intertitles
Why Be Good? is a 1929 American sound comedy film produced by First National Pictures starring Colleen Moore and Neil Hamilton. While the film has no audible dialogue, it is accompanied by a Vitaphone soundtrack that features a musical score with sound effects and some synchronized singing.[1]
Plot
Winthrop Peabody Jr. and his friends prepare to frolic into the night before he must begin work the following day at his father's department store. Before departing, Winthrop Peabody Sr. lectures his son about women and warns him to avoid the store's female employees.
Pert Kelly, after winning a dance contest, is wooed by gentlemen of questionable character. Pert catches the eye of Peabody Jr., who drives her home and schedules a date for the following night. Because she was out late, Pert is tardy to work and must report to the personnel office, where she is surprised to find Peabody Jr. working. Peabody Sr. sees what has happened and fires Pert.
Peabody Jr. explains to Pert that it was not he who had terminated her, and they schedule another date. Lavish gifts arrive for Pert to wear to the next date. Her father admonishes her about the lack of virtues of the modern man, and Peabody Sr. repeats his warning to his son.
On the next date, Peabody Jr. has devised a test of Pert's virtue. When he tries to push her past her personal limits, she protests and passes his test. They are married that night and prove her virtue to Peabody Sr., who cannot now refute it.
Cast
- Colleen Moore as Pert Kelly
- Neil Hamilton as Winthrop Peabody Jr.
- Bodil Rosing as Ma Kelly
- John St. Polis as Pa Kelly
- Edward Martindel as Winthrop Peabody Sr.
- Louis Natheaux as Jimmy Alexander
- Eddie Clayton as Tim
- Lincoln Stedman as Jerry
- Collette Merton as Julie
- Dixie Carter as Susie
Music
The film featured a theme song entitled "I'm Thirsty for Kisses - Hungry for Love" with words and music by Lou Davis and J. Fred Coots.
Censorship
Like many American films of the time, Why Be Good? was subject to cuts by city and state film censorship boards. In Kansas the film, with its plot of a test of the virtue of a young woman, was banned by the Board of Review.[2]
Preservation
Why Be Good? had been considered a lost film for many decades, with only the film's Vitaphone soundtrack still in existence.[3] In the late 1990s, a 35mm print of the film was discovered in the archives of the Cineteca Italiana.[3] Restoration work was completed in 2014, funded by Warner Bros. and The Vitaphone Project.[4]
The U.S. premiere of the restoration was hosted by the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences at the Los Angeles County Museum of Art's Bing Theater on September 6, 2014.[5] This same restoration was released on DVD-R by the Warner Archive Collection on October 28, 2014 and screened at New York's Film Forum on November 9, 2014.[6][7] It was later aired on the Turner Classic Movies channel.
See also
- List of early sound feature films (1926–1929)
References
Notes
- ^ Why Be Good? at silentera.com
- ^ Butters, Gerald R. (2007). Banned in Kansas: Motion Picture Censorship, 1915-1966. University of Missouri Press. p. 195. ISBN 978-0-8262-1749-3.
- ^ a b Ferdinand, Marilyn. "Why Be Good?". San Francisco Silent Film Festival. Retrieved January 29, 2024.
- ^ Smith, Imogen Sara. "TCM Diary: Vitaphone Varieties". Film Comment. Film at Lincoln Center. Retrieved January 29, 2024.
- ^ ""Why Be Good?" Celebrates The Jazz Age". LADailyMirror.com. September 9, 2014. Retrieved December 7, 2014.
- ^ "Why Be Good?". Silentera.com. Retrieved January 29, 2024.
- ^ "Why Be Good?". Film Forum. Film Forum, Inc. Retrieved January 29, 2024.
Bibliography
- Codori, Jeff (2012), Colleen Moore; A Biography of the Silent Film Star, McFarland Publishing,(Print ISBN 978-0-7864-4969-9, EBook ISBN 978-0-7864-8899-5).
External links
- Why Be Good? at IMDb
- Why Be Good? at the TCM Movie Database
- Why Be Good? at AllMovie
- Why Be Good? at the AFI Catalog of Feature Films
- Why Be Good? at SilentEra
- AFI Catalog of Feature Films
- Why Be Good soundtrack at the Internet Archive
- v
- t
- e
- The Kentucky Colonel (1920)
- Eden and Return (1921)
- Hearts and Masks (1921)
- The Foolish Age (1921)
- Passing Through (1921)
- Boy Crazy (1922)
- Gay and Devilish (1922)
- Up and at 'Em (1922)
- When Love Comes (1922)
- The Understudy (1922)
- The Beautiful and Damned (1922)
- Little Church Around the Corner (1923)
- Daddies (1924)
- His Forgotten Wife (1924)
- The White Sin (1924)
- Listen Lester (1924)
- The Family Secret (1924)
- Helen's Babies (1924)
- The Fast Worker (1924)
- The Mad Whirl (1925)
- Dangerous Innocence (1925)
- The Teaser (1925)
- Where Was I? (1925)
- What Happened to Jones (1926)
- Skinner's Dress Suit (1926)
- Rolling Home (1926)
- Take It from Me (1926)
- The Cheerful Fraud (1927)
- The Small Bachelor (1927)
- Thanks for the Buggy Ride (1928)
- Good Morning, Judge (1928)
- Waterfront (1928)
- Outcast (1928)
- Synthetic Sin (1929)
- Why Be Good? (1929)
- Smiling Irish Eyes (1929)
- Footlights and Fools (1929)
- The Love Racket (1929)
- Strictly Modern (1930)
- Back Pay (1930)
- The Truth About Youth (1930)
- Sunny (1930)
- Going Wild (1930)
- Kiss Me Again (1931)
- Big Business Girl (1931)
- Too Many Cooks (1931)
- Caught Plastered (1931)
- Way Back Home (1931)
- Girl Crazy (1932)
- Young Bride (1932)
- Is My Face Red? (1932)
- Hot Saturday (1932)
- If I Had a Million (segment "The Three Marines", 1932)
- Hello, Everybody! (1933)
- Diplomaniacs (1933)
- Rafter Romance (1933)
- Chance at Heaven (1933)
- Sons of the Desert (1933)
- Love Birds (1934)
- We're Rich Again (1934)
- The Richest Girl in the World (1934)
- Roberta (1935)
- The Daring Young Man (1935)
- If You Could Only Cook (1935)
- The Case Against Mrs. Ames (1936)
- The Moon's Our Home (1936)
- Dimples (1936)
- Stowaway (1936)
- Life Begins in College (1937)
- This Is My Affair (1937)
- Sally, Irene and Mary (1938)
- Room Service (1938)
- Thanks for Everything (1938)
- Susannah of the Mounties (1939)
- Allegheny Uprising (1939)
- It's a Date (1940)
- Hired Wife (1940)
- Nice Girl? (1941)
- Appointment for Love (1941)
- Broadway (1942)
- You Were Never Lovelier (1942)
- Destroyer (1943)
- A Lady Takes a Chance (1943)
- Four Jills in a Jeep (1944)
- Belle of the Yukon (1944)
- The Affairs of Susan (1945)
- That Night with You (1945)
- Little Giant (1946)
- I'll Be Yours (1947)
- Up in Central Park (1948)
- One Touch of Venus (1948)
- Borderline (1950)
- Dear Brat (1951)
- The Lady Wants Mink (1953)
- Champ for a Day (1953)
- Make Haste to Live (1954)